“Yellow Fish” Cottage

Reviews

1. Hi Marty - thanks for your review. We apologize that this condo was not up to your standards and that the linens delivered were not what you were hoping for. This was our busiest week of the entire summer and we really were trying to do our best and get the linens to you timely. Again, our apologies they weren't there for your 4pm check-in. We do not advertise or show photos of a kitchen table and we think the island/bar area is very spacious and wonderful. We are sorry that you didn't like the wooden stools provided. This is a very nicely decorated, clean and modern condo that people absolutely love and rent year after year. Again, we do apologize that it was not up to your standards. I'm sorry that you did not like the laminated signs. I do know that the owners have very nice laminated signs throughout the property for specific instructions, but will recommend a binder. We wish you the best of luck in your future travels. Take care! Tina Torcivia

   —Tina T., September 2021

2. We stayed at Yellow Fish in July 2021. The location was great. There are a couple of things to consider before renting this condominium. We paid $100.00 for linens and towels that were supposed to be there when we arrived, they were not. We had to call 2 times before they were delivered, at 7:30 pm. The linens looked like they came from my Grandmother's attic or a garage sale. The fitted sheet was stained with red pen or red marker. The sheet sets did not match, the towels were thread worn. I would suggest bringing your own sheets and towels. In addition, there isn't a kitchen table, there is a peninsula with 5 uncomfortable bar stools. We wanted to play cards/games at night, there wasn't a table to do so. Also, the furniture is fabric and holds previous smells and odors. The family room area smells like smelly gym shoes. I suggest leather furniture instead. Also, there were approximately 15 laminated signs taped on the kitchen cabinets and doors. These should be in a binder on the kitchen counter, like most rentals. These signs are very tacky.

   —Marty S., August 2021

3. Our stay was just wonderful! The location of this cottage is perfect in Fish Creek -- what more could you ask for being steps away from the Peninsula State Park and shops/restaurants and an ice cream shop? The cottage is very clean and well appointed with new furniture, new floor and a great kitchen, grill and washer/dryer. We felt as comfortable as we were at home. It has been 15+ years since we have been to Door County and knowing we can stay at this great place we will certainly be back for a visit very soon. Thank you! Karen A-K, July 2020

   —Karen A., July 2020

4. We enjoyed our stay here immensely! Very clean and updated. We were so impressed with all of the added details and decor. Felt like home while we were there! Location is great because it is within walking distance of pretty much everything in Fish Creek. Glad we booked this wonderful space!

   —Amy C., July 2020

5. What a beautiful, thoughtfully appointed rental. Close to everything, but tucked away just a bit to give you peace & quiet. The cottage is up to date with high end details and beautiful comfortable furnishings. Absolutely perfect for 2 couples wanting to get away from it all. Will keep on my list of "best" places for a get away.

   —Nora L., September 2019